Scott Gaynor
5.00 92 Reviews 
AN
January 2025 Maryland

Excellent transaction!

AN
January 2025 New York

BUYER BEWARE* spent over a grand on the auction buts let's discuss the $300 lot on yu gi oh and Pokemon cards. They advertised as "some 1996 originals, Mostly NM-MT to MINT, etc" THEY FAILED TO MENTION OR SHOW OVER 300 FAKE cards. Beyond disgusted and very obviously deceived. Listing not accurate at all. On top of that the OG blue-eyes-white dragon is "missing" from the lot. It was shown to be in the lot however upon receiving my items they obviously swapped it out with a FAKE one like I wouldn't know. Either this was gross negligence by an employee, or just outright fraud by the owner.

Gaynor's Fine Consignments
The 1996 cards are not fake, but variants of the 1996 cards (as mentioned in the description). As for cards not there, everything that is pictured in included and nothing is missing. It would appear that this buyer didn't read the description.
 
AN
January 2025 NH

I've bought multiple lots from Gaynors FC and they are always exceptional. The items are exactly as described, well packaged and delivered incredibly quickly at a very fair shipping price. I've reached out with questions before and got responses right away.

AN
January 2025 Connecticut

Great transaction.

AN
January 2025 Maryland

Everything as described

AN
January 2025 Maryland

Great transaction

AN
January 2025 Maryland

Great transaction.

AN
January 2025 New York

Seller listed a Hank Aaron baseball card as being in G/VG condition but he is mistaken. The card is in very poor condition. It's torn and has multiple creases through it. A guy who sells as many cards as he does should know what poor condition is...oh well.

Gaynor's Fine Consignments
Sorry to hear that you are unhappy but grading is subjective. I offered a refund, but the buyer declined.
 
AN
January 2025 Tennessee

Great Experience! A+++++

AN
January 2025 Connecticut

Fast shipping, great items, Thank you very much.